Posted by: E (The Third Glance) | October 28, 2012

Autism, Reading Comprehension, and my experience with reading

There’s been a number of posts recently about autistic kids learning to read. Start of school and such, I guess. (This post from Ib at Tiny Grace Notes, a learning-to-read question from Outrunning the Storm, and a post from Ariane, over at Emma’s Hope Book about reading comprehension and homeworks all bring up reading and reading comprehension.) What follows is an expanded version of the comment response I made to Ariane’s post, about my experiences with reading comprehension. This isn’t everything, of course, but it’s a few thoughts that might be worthwhile for some of you or your kids. 🙂

—————————–

A little history of me and reading:

I learned to read when I was very young. Preschool aged. It was something that I could do that didn’t involve people talking to me, and I loved it. I would read everything in front of me: signs, magazines, books, labels, etc. I even read every single bottle of shampoo and soap in the shower. Anything with text was fair game, and I was good at reading. My parents got me my very first library card on my 5th birthday – you had to be 5 to have a library card, so that was my birthday present. I still have that little card, and it’s still valid. And I read anything and everything I could get my hands on.

———————————————

When I was in 2nd grade, I read Lord of the Rings (my dad had read me The Hobbit the year prior, and it seemed only natural that this should be my next major thing to read). I loved it. I understood the story, could get lost in a book in a moment’s notice. I was always a very advanced reader, and reading was my solace. Unlike many other autistic individuals I’ve met or read about, I loved fiction books, especially fantasy and sci-fi books. They took me to worlds where people acted differently. They had set rules and worlds, and I’m a sucker for a well-developed world. I actually learned most of my “how to read facial expressions” by fiction books. Words like “his brow knotted together in concentration” or “her eyes widened in surprise, her eyebrows nearly disappearing into her hairline” taught me what faces people made when they were thinking something. Even now, I use what I learned in my books to understand many nonverbal cues. But that is an aside.

Despite being an extremely skilled reader, able to tackle books meant for people more than twice my age, I couldn’t read aloud to save my life. We would do this thing in school called reading groups where 5-8 kids would sit around a table, all with the same story in front of us, and we’d each read a sentence (or a paragraph) aloud, and rotate around the table until the story was done. Reading aloud was horrible for me, because it went much too slow. I would be so bored that I’d take off and read the whole rest of the story while the other students struggled to read their sentences aloud, then when it was my turn again, I’d have no idea where we were, because I had already finished that short story and moved on to the next one. Plus, my speech skills couldn’t keep up with my reading skills, and I’d often miss whole words and lines when reading aloud. It was miserable. I still have a lot of trouble reading aloud, but luckily, I don’t have to do so very often. Speech is hard for me, reading is easy. Put the two together and you end up with a giant mess of confusion where my brain’s verbalizing center can’t keep up with my brain’s reading center, and I just get more and more stressed and confused until something snaps.

I have always had the unique ability of being able to open a book (novel) I’d put down months prior and pick up wherever I left off. Within a sentence or two, I am right back in the story. My mind would completely paint a picture, and it is almost like I’m living within the world of the story. I understand what I’m reading. Enjoy what I’m reading, LOVE what I’m reading. But I don’t process books (especially fiction books) as words. It’s like my brain takes the foreign words and translates them into my own language, the one I understand implicitly, without any trouble. Yet ask me specifics about what happened or why, and I’m lost. I can’t recall that information, especially if the question uses a different sentence or words than what is in the text. I could tell people about the story in my own words, but answering their questions was always a challenge. My brain doesn’t convert other people’s experiences of a text into something I can understand and answer easily, despite understanding the text itself.

It was always a mystery to my teachers how I could so easily read books meant for people more than twice my age, and tell them about the books, but how I couldn’t read aloud or pass basic reading comprehension exams. But I couldn’t. (I got a perfect 800 on my math SAT, but a 680 in verbal “reading comprehension” – I know this is a very good score by most standards, but it’s highly uneven compared to my other scores, and representative to how I’ve always been on exams. Same thing happened on the GRE, except my verbal score was even lower.) On our state exams, from the first time I took them in early elementary school to the last, I scored perfect in math, and anywhere from “remedial” to “just above average” in the reading comprehension. I didn’t get it – I’m a good reader, I love reading. Obviously, there’s a disconnect between my reading ability and the testing of it. By the time I was in high school, I had mostly figured out how I can make the reading comprehension questions “work” at least somewhat for me, and what follows is MY solution.

I survived “reading comprehension” by reading and thinking about the questions FIRST, before reading the text. I would try to understand what it was they were asking in my own words. I would rephrase things I perceived as “important” parts of the question multiple different ways, so it was in my brain. Why? Because then I knew exactly what I had to look for in the text. I could then read, looking for the keywords I knew would be relevant, and answer the questions as they came up. I hated doing this, because it meant that I was missing most of the point of the text. I could understand a sentence, maybe two at a time, tops. I would be able to process almost nothing. Yet I could answer most (but not all) of the questions. Those questions of “what was the author feeling when s/he wrote this passage?” and “what value is the author trying to portray in line 12?” will always be a mystery to me. Sometimes I can guess right, but seriously, I have NO IDEA if the author was trying to tell me something or not. My absolute “favorite” of this type of question is “would the author of passage 9 agree with the author of passage 12 on some topic that is only vaguely related to either topic addressed in passages 9 and 12?” – HOW THE HECK SHOULD I KNOW? I’ve never met the authors. I’ve read a whole 3 paragraphs written by each of them. And who knows if those paragraphs are actually representative of how they feel about any topic? Can you see the frustration? Now these are more “advanced” reading comprehension questions – I didn’t start seeing these until middle school, but they still haunt me today. I’m so glad that the part of my life where these types of exams can help determine my future is over.

For more basic reading comprehension questions, the ones where you’re trying to determine if the young person in question has actually read and absorbed any of the story/text they are supposed to be reading, I think the best thing for me, was to be able to have a discussion about it. When I read something, ask me to say what I think it is about. Then use MY vocabulary to shape your questions. I could tell you about it in my own words, but the instant you ask me in YOUR words, I’m lost. And that’s what reading comprehension questions are, for the most part. They’re someone else’s interpretation of a story. It’s a valid interpretation, just as my interpretation is valid, but often they are different. What I take away from a text may be similar to what you take away, but it may not. And far more relevantly, it might be the same idea, but different words. Different words stump me, frustrate me, and confuse me. Just because I can’t answer all of those questions doesn’t mean I can’t read.

Advertisements

Responses

  1. Read the LOTR 27 times. Probably explains a lot.

  2. Okay first, before I could even begin commenting, I had to google “what does LOTR mean”. I bring this up because this is my fundamental problem with so many things. I am easily sidetracked. So when I am confronted with questions like “would the author of passage 9 agree with the author of passage 12″ I’d have to reread passage 12, get (probably) all caught up in some obscure detail or last sentence whichever was more compelling, then go to passage 9, do the same, only to have forgotten the gist of passage 12 requiring me to reread that again, and on it would go.
    Thank you for writing this post. I loved the comment you left and am grateful for the longer version!

  3. Did you ever have difficulty with pronouns? My son has a lot of trouble with following pronouns and while he can read and use text to search the web at age six, he still does not follow the stories that use pronouns. Just wondering.

    • I have in the past had trouble with pronouns, but usually I’m ok with them. Something that helped me early on was simple one paragraph stories with pronouns that I could then go through and figure out which pronoun went to which person, and write it in. So basically I’d read the story once, then go through it, find all the pronouns and write the names of who went where, then read the story again. That helped a lot. And now when I get stuck on a pronoun, all I do is stop and look back. Sometimes I do get confused, though, and it leads to comedic things.

  4. I also had trouble with reading comprehension, but did well in math. However, I had trouble with math problems — probably because they require you to have good reading comprehension. Did you have trouble with math problems, too?

  5. Nice post. I resonate with a lot of that, early reading, being sent home to learn words like ‘cat’ and ‘mat’ and mum sending me back with ‘television’ and ‘alphabet’; but difficulty recalling to answer people’s questions and always struggled with English literature at school,

  6. I share your pain when it comes to reading comprehension questions. I was an early reader too and finished my elementary school’s reading curriculum in 4th grade – it was a progressive, go at your own pace program and I burned through it so fast they ended up letting me choose novels and then meet with the teacher to talk about them to keep me busy.

    But SAT and GRE reading comp questions? I’ve given up even trying and tend to just guess. Reading this has finally explained to me why I struggle so much and why the questions can be so infuriating. Thank you for taking the time to share this. It’s very helpful!

  7. This is such an excellent article! I especially love the last sentence!!

  8. This is so interesting to me. You’ve described my son (who is not on the spectrum as far as we know) almost perfectly. He loves to read and has been able to read books well above grade level since he started. But, he HATES questions on standardized tests that ask for his opinion about something in a “multiple choice” format. He asked me, quite pointedly, “How can you ask my opinion, then give me four choices? Aren’t you just asking me to guess someone ELSE’s opinion?” As a teacher, I could not argue with his logic. He also really struggles with the “what feeling was the author trying to convey” type questions. I don’t blame him. I think any author worth his salt will tell you that she isn’t *trying* to convey a feeling, she’s trying to convey a story that will impact her readers in hundreds or thousands of individualized ways.

    But, I especially loved your description of how reading helped you learn facial cues. I’d not considered how important that might be, and I’m happy to have learned that as I continue to teach my daughter (autism) how to read. We made her a special book that shows people making faces consistent with certain feelings (e.g., happy, sad, surprised). But, I wonder if putting those in context of a story, with words that describe the characteristics of an expression, would help even more. I will certainly try it.

    Thank you for opening another window for me, E. Always so grateful!

  9. Hm. I never had problems with reading comp questions… but everything else, especially:
    – loving science fiction and fantasy
    – reading adult novels as a child (I moved from the children’s to the young adults’ section in my library by the time I was 8, and to the adults’ section by the time I was 10)
    – learning facial reactions (and body language reactions) through reading authors’ descriptions

    Reading just made my whole world open up, and let me create my own worlds where I was comfortable, and didn’t have to deal with the pressures and anxieties of the real world.

    🙂 tagAught


Please Share Your Thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

%d bloggers like this: